Understanding the meaning of a criminal is an important foundation in Criminology. However, the definition may differ depending on whether we examine criminal behavior from a criminological or legal perspective. This distinction is particularly important when answering Criminologist Licensure Examination (CLE) questions.
In this lesson, we will examine the meaning of criminological sense, understand the concept of anti-social behavior, and distinguish it from the legal meaning of criminal conduct.
CLE Practice Question
Question:
A person is already considered a criminal the moment he committed any anti-social act.
What is the correct answer?
- Common sense
- Criminological sense
- Legal sense
- Scientific sense
Correct Answer: B. Criminological Sense
The most defensible answer is Criminological sense.
The question refers to the broader criminological perspective of studying criminal behavior and anti-social conduct. Criminology examines behavior that deviates from accepted social norms and investigates the causes, consequences, and social responses associated with such behavior.
What Is Criminological Sense?
Criminological sense refers to the broader perspective used in studying criminality and anti-social behavior. It focuses on the behavior of individuals, the circumstances that influence their actions, and the relationship between individual conduct and society.
Criminology is not limited to identifying offenses prohibited by law. It also studies the social, psychological, biological, and environmental factors associated with criminal behavior.
For example, criminologists may examine:
- Why individuals engage in anti-social behavior.
- How family relationships and social environments influence behavior.
- How poverty, peer influence, and social conditions may relate to criminality.
- How society responds to deviant and criminal behavior.
- How crime prevention and rehabilitation programs can reduce offending.
Therefore, the criminological perspective is broader than simply determining whether an individual has violated a particular penal provision.
Understanding Anti-Social Acts
An anti-social act refers to behavior that goes against accepted social norms, values, or expectations. Such behavior may disregard the rights, welfare, or interests of other members of society.
Examples of conduct that may be considered anti-social include:
- Persistent bullying and intimidation.
- Harassment and aggressive behavior.
- Deliberate disregard for the welfare of others.
- Conduct that seriously disrupts community relationships.
However, an important distinction must be emphasized: Not every anti-social act is automatically a criminal offense.
Some behavior may be socially unacceptable without being specifically prohibited and penalized by Philippine criminal law.
Criminological Sense vs. Legal Sense
One of the important distinctions in introductory Criminology is understanding the difference between the broader study of criminal behavior and the legal determination of criminal conduct.
| Basis | Criminological Sense | Legal Sense |
|---|---|---|
| Perspective | Social and behavioral perspective | Legal perspective |
| Main focus | Criminality, anti-social behavior, and its causes | Acts prohibited and penalized by law |
| Coverage | Broader study of behavior and social conditions | Conduct covered by applicable penal laws |
| Important consideration | Understanding criminal behavior and its relationship with society | Establishing criminal liability under applicable law |
Important: The distinction above is a simplified educational comparison. In Philippine law, a person accused of a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt. Merely being suspected of committing an offense does not establish criminal guilt.
Why Is the Answer Not Legal Sense?
The legal perspective requires examining whether the particular act is prohibited and penalized by law.
Under Philippine criminal law, not every undesirable or anti-social behavior constitutes a criminal offense. There must be an applicable legal provision establishing the prohibited conduct and its corresponding penalty.
Furthermore, criminal liability must be established through the proper legal process.
For this reason, the wording of the question, particularly the expression anti-social act, points toward the broader criminological perspective rather than a strict legal determination of guilt.
Explanation of the Other Choices
A. Common Sense
Common sense refers to ordinary practical judgment or the ability to make reasonable decisions based on everyday experience. It is not the specific academic perspective described in the question.
B. Criminological Sense
Correct answer. This is the broader perspective that examines criminality, anti-social behavior, and the relationship between individual conduct and society.
C. Legal Sense
This concerns conduct prohibited and penalized by law and the establishment of criminal liability under applicable legal rules. It is narrower than the broader behavioral and social perspective discussed in the question.
D. Scientific Sense
Scientific sense generally refers to an approach based on systematic observation, investigation, and evidence. Although criminology uses scientific methods, this is not the specific classification being tested.
Practical Example
Consider an individual who repeatedly engages in bullying and intimidation within a community.
A criminologist may study the individual's behavior, family background, social environment, psychological factors, and possible motivations to understand the anti-social conduct.
That is an example of a criminological approach.
However, if the particular conduct also violates a criminal statute, the legal perspective will examine the applicable offense, the required elements, the available evidence, and whether criminal liability can be established.
This example demonstrates why criminological analysis and legal determination should not be confused.
Board Examination Tips
- Criminological sense: Think of criminal behavior, anti-social conduct, and the study of criminality.
- Legal sense: Think of penal laws, prohibited acts, and criminal liability.
- Common sense: Think of ordinary practical judgment.
- Scientific sense: Think of systematic investigation and evidence-based methods.
Common examination trap: Do not automatically equate every anti-social act with a criminal offense. An act may violate social expectations without necessarily violating a penal law.
Memory Aid: CRIMINOLOGICAL vs. LEGAL
Remember this simple distinction:
- CRIMINOLOGICAL = BEHAVIOR. Focuses on criminality, anti-social conduct, and the causes of behavior.
- LEGAL = LAW. Focuses on prohibited acts, penal provisions, and criminal liability.
When a CLE question emphasizes anti-social behavior and the broader study of criminality, consider the criminological perspective.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is criminological sense?
Criminological sense refers to the broader perspective of examining criminality and anti-social behavior, including the causes, patterns, and social consequences of such behavior.
2. What is legal sense?
Legal sense concerns conduct prohibited and penalized by law. It also involves the legal standards and procedures used to determine criminal responsibility.
3. Is every anti-social act a crime?
No. Some acts may violate social norms without constituting a criminal offense. For an act to be criminal under Philippine law, it must fall within an applicable penal provision.
4. Why is criminology broader than criminal law?
Criminology examines crime and criminal behavior from multiple perspectives, including social, psychological, biological, and environmental factors. Criminal law primarily establishes prohibited conduct, penalties, and the legal principles governing criminal liability.
Conclusion
The correct answer to the question is B. Criminological sense.
The key concept is that criminology studies criminality and anti-social behavior from a broader social and behavioral perspective. Legal analysis, on the other hand, focuses on acts prohibited by law and the establishment of criminal liability.
For CLE preparation, remember the distinction: Criminological sense focuses on behavior, while legal sense focuses on the law.
Prepare for Your CLE with SLRC
Strengthen your criminology knowledge through consistent practice and a better understanding of important board examination concepts.
St. Louis Review Center provides a FREE online reviewer designed to help criminology students practice and improve their understanding.
- FREE Practice Tests
- Unlimited Attempts
- Complete Rationales
- Mobile Friendly
Access the SLRC Free Online Reviewer here:
START YOUR FREE CLE REVIEW WITH SLRC
Visit our official website:
St. Louis Review Center – Official Website
Follow us for more board examination questions, lessons, and review materials:
SLRC — Board Exams Made Easy.